Science will prevail

Science Will Prevail

Re: Aug. 31 article, “Scientists: Climate is deeply flawed”

It is beyond mind boggling and painful to see what the Trump administration wants the Environmental Protection Agency and Department of Energy to repeal climate regulation and cherry-pick scientific findings to create doubt on proven facts, no matter what it does to the health of people.

According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the U.S. had an average of 3.7 events per year with a loss of more than $1 billion between 1980 and 1989. That shot up to an average of 18 events per year between 2013 and 2022. Each such event wrecks lives and livelihoods, and 2.3 million Texans who live within a half mile of oil and gas operations would be at a greater risk of methane pollution without these rules.

If rescinded, such irresponsible and cynical actions would be devastating for many. You can oppose repeal of “endangerment finding” of 2009 by submitting comments by September 21 through the EPA website.

Peer-reviewed research by scientists will stand the test of time.

Published by the Austin American-Statesman on September 6, 2025, in Opinions//Letters

Kalpana Sutaria, Member, Citizens’ Climate Lobby Austin, Architect, Author, and an environmental advocate dedicated to tackling Global Warming Challenges

Kalana Sutaria Book from Atmosphere

Why Do People Need to Celebrate Earth Day? The Answer Should Be Obvious

Earth Day. Why do we even need one?

For 150,000 years of human existence, we numbered only a miniscule few million at most. Earth was a vast ocean of non-human nature in which there were tiny islands of human impact. In the past 75-100 years these tiny islands have grown to the size of continents. A hundred years ago there were just under 2 billion of us. We now number more than 8 billion, soon to hit 10-12 billion. And the average environmental impact per person has far more than quadrupled.

It became obvious that a concerted effort was needed to protect our lovely planet earth. In 1970 the Environmental Protection Act was passed. Earth Day was born.

In the years after 1970, we congratulated ourselves on real improvements in environmental health. Our creeks no longer looked like soapsuds-filled bathtubs. The Cuyahoga River no longer caught fire. Little did we realize that for every step forward we made, we were taking two steps back.

In the past few decades, man has been the cause of the decimation of countless species, and increased the species extinction rate to hundreds or even thousands of times the normal rate. We have created more than 80,000 chemicals that never existed in earth’s 4 billion year history. A number of them exist in the bodies of living creatures, yours included; evidence exists that many are harmful to life, but we have tested just a tiny fraction of them for long-term impacts.

We have measurably changed the acidity of the oceans, which experts expect to drop by the end of this century to a pH level not experienced in more than 14 million years, impacting ocean ecologies, food supplies, and the world economy. We will soon have heated earth to 1.5C warmer than pre-industrial temperatures and are on track to heat 2.5-3C warmer by 2100, higher than it has been in millions of years. Summer arctic ice is shrinking by more than 12% per decade. Desertification and increasingly punishing droughts are creating water scarcity, impacting food production the world over, including our U.S. Southwest.

We are rapidly depleting groundwater resources worldwide. It is likely our heating of the oceans will disrupt ocean currents that would disrupt climate in heavily populated Atlantic nations. A quarter of marine life depends upon healthy coral reefs for important parts of their life cycle, and by 2030 it is estimated that 90% of them will be threatened by human activities, with nearly 60% facing high to critical threat levels. The oceans are filled with many millions of tons of plastic, not only in the grossly large form of sacks, bottles, and six-pack rings, but also microplastics too small to see, which enter the oceanic and human food chain.

Our list of serious environmental challenges can seem overwhelming, leading to despair and denial. But if we recognize the problems and commit to resolving them, we can. We almost succeeded in destroying the earth’s ozone layer but were able to come together to create multi-national agreements that nearly eliminated the production and release of ozone-depleting chemicals.

We can do the same for protecting our overall earthly environment if we make a concerted effort. A movement is afoot, the so-called 30×30 initiative, proposed in 2019, to protect 30% of earth’s land and sea areas from human activity by the year 2030. As of Dec 2022, 190 nations had signed on to this initiative. Though a 50×50 plan is more in line with what is needed, 30×30 is a hopeful first step – only if nations live up to their words. 

So the need for Earth Day is obvious, and it is fitting that we have a special, once a year commemoration. We need to put into practice that every single day of the year is Earth Day.

Mark Warren

A native Austinite, Warren is a volunteer with Citizens Climate Lobby and has studied climate and environmental issues for years. 

Published by the Austin American-Statesman

April 21, 2024

Thank you for printing a lovely commentary on Earth Day. We all dislike pollution, and we know that it can wipe out entire species, but do we know how much it harms us? Over 60,000 Americans die prematurely every year from air pollution, most of which comes from burning fossil fuels. This is equivalent to a fully loaded jumbo jet crashing every three days, with no survivors. We don’t have to live this way anymore. There are cleaner ways to produce energy. We need to let our leaders know that we want to breathe deeply and live.

Marie Miglin, PhD.

Volunteering as Co-Leader, Austin Metro Chapter, Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Consulting Engineer with 35 years in the energy sector

mtmiglin@gmail.com

What do Texans Want on Earth Day 2024?

The year 2023 was the hottest year since 1850 exceeding the previous record set by 2016 per the Berkley Earth. Austinites experienced the record-breaking temperatures last summer with meteorologists raising alarms for outdoor workers. The state climatologist Dr. John Neilson-Gammon has assessment report of extreme weather in Texas as it continues to worsen.

The State of Texas is a leader in oil and gas production, and it leads the nation in wind power generation, and it is almost at the top in generation of solar power. It is also the largest emitter of greenhouse gases in our nation. Without Texas, our nation cannot decarbonize itself. If Texas were a country, it would be the eighth largest economy and the eighth largest emitter of greenhouse gas emissions in the world. Texas’ actions to curb emissions would hugely improve the environment.

With these facts, the Citizens’ Climate Lobby’s (CCL) leadership approached the Texas State Legislature in its 2023 session. Legislative sessions are held once every two years for 140 days. It is difficult for constituents to bring up issues to state lawmakers, when work of all committees and two state houses must be sorted through the number of bills filed, in a very short time. Important issues remain unaddressed.

Policy decisions made by Texas Legislature affect the energy industry as well as Texans. How we generate and transport energy has a profound impact on our environment. The major ask of 10,000 volunteers of CCL was to improve the electric grid that transmits electricity from power plants to consumers. The problem was that transmission lines were not adequate to transmit all renewable energy that was generated, creating a backlog. CCL volunteers held 66 meetings with the state representatives of both parties. A year later, the backlog still exists, and transmission lines are not fully fixed. Generated energy’s backlog, and transmission bottlenecks such as these cost Texans over $5 billion in 2022 and 2023. Consumers, the State, and the environment – all of them will benefit if lawmakers enact the right policies.

Methane leaks from oil and gas production in Texas hugely affect the environment because methane is a potent greenhouse gas that is 80 times more warming than carbon dioxide (CO 2 ). It stays in the air for decades rather than for centuries like CO2 does. Methane leaks and gas flaring are known to the authorities and oil and gas producers. Texas regulators have not enforced them fully. The new climate regulation by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) will require the oil and gas operators to reduce methane leaks. Per EPA, these rules can prevent equivalent of 1.5 billion tons of CO2 being emitted between 2024 and 2038, almost equal to emissions by all power plants in the country in 2021. Fixing methane leaks helps the operators too, but still Texas has challenged the rules.

CCL supports climate solutions that grow economic opportunities, that are market based, cost effective, efficient and are implemented in a socially equitable manner. The climate crisis has highlighted the already existing inequities. It is worse for those who have fewer resources to live through any type of climate disasters – like flooding, drought, wildfires, sea level rise, extreme heat or cold – causing physical and psychological stress on people.

We must not forget that global warming continues to accelerate. The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) is delivering positive outcomes to combat the climate crisis. The State of Texas can take advantage of many available opportunities for emissions reductions in the IRA helping Texans. It has tax benefits for removal of accumulated carbon in the atmosphere for businesses.

On this Earth Day, we want lawmakers to implement all policies to lower emissions and improve health and well-being of Texans.

Kalpana Sutaria

Project Manager, City of Austin and Member, Austin Metro Chapter, Citizens’ Climate Lobby

Submitted to the Austin American-Statesman

April 2024

  1. Rohde, Robert (2024), Global Temperature Report for 2023.
  2. Texas Economic Development Corporation, “Texas Economic Strength.”
  3. Environment Texas, “The Top Ten Biggest Global Warming Polluters in Texas.”
  4. Grid Monitor, The Texas grid did its job during the freeze, but the job’s not done.
  5. IEA, Methane and Climate Change.
  6. Federal Register, EPA Methane regulations issued on March 8, 2024.

Earth Day 2023

We all deserve to breathe clean air and drink clean water. There is nothing partisan about it. It was because of concerns about clean air and clean water that the Earth Day tradition began. Thousands of students and other groups fought against oil spills, pollution from factories and power plants, raw sewage, toxic dumps, pesticides, species extinction and loss of wilderness. The first Earth Day was celebrated on April 22, 1970. Republicans and Democrats, rich and poor, urban and rural dwellers, farmers, business and labor leaders came together demanding better environment.

By the end of 1970, the United States Environmental Protection Agency was created and the U.S. Congress passed environmental laws including the National Environmental Education Act, the Occupational Safety and Health Act and the Clean Air Act and in 1972 it passed the Clean Water Act. These laws have saved lives, improved air quality and health.

For two decades, concerns about increased use of coal, oil and gas were raised by not only NASA’s climate scientists but by ExxonMobil’s own scientists. Increased use of coal, oil and gas added pollutants including carbon dioxide (CO2) in the air. In 1988, Dr. Hansen testified in the U.S. Congress expressing concerns of global warming. By 1990, Earth Day was globally celebrated by nations for global action. Since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, human activities have produced 40 percent more atmospheric concentration of CO2, from 280 ppm to 414.7 ppm in 2021. Carbon dioxide emissions reached record high in 2022.

Seventeen out of eighteen warmest years have occurred since 2001 according to NASA.

As concentrations of CO2 and other greenhouse gas emissions increase in the atmosphere, extreme weather events have intensified, our climate has destabilized and pollutants and pollen counts have gone up. Austin is known for problems of pollen allergies throughout the year. Pollen allergies have become much worse with increase in CO2, warmer temperatures and tail pipe emissions resulting from traffic congestion. Austin had 25 “Ozone Action Days” in 2022 which tops the combined total for past eight years. Short term measures like reduction in use of gasoline powered vehicles, equipment and manufacturing and long term measures like transitioning to cleaner energy sources are needed to reduce warming and ground level ozone. People suffering from pollen allergies feel the effects of ground level ozone along with increase in pollens from ragweed, grass, mold, trees and other pollutants. Sneezing, headaches, post nasal drainage and general sense of tiredness are the symptoms that I suffer from, even after taking appropriate measures.

Texas is a leader in oil and gas production. A non-profit group, Carbon Mapper has detected methane leaks near drilling sites in Texas. Methane has more than 80 times the warming power of CO2 for 20 years after its release. Methane emissions cause 25% of global warming today. Lack of enforcement of permitting rules on oil and gas operations continue to add to global warming by releasing methane into our environment.

Texas faces many water issues including groundwater pollution, aging infrastructure, drought and flooding. Abandoned oil and gas wells are polluting Texas farms, ranches, and underground water. Texas Railroad Commission (TRCC) which oversees orphan wells in Texas, has reported 140,000 inactive wells. Until these wells are plugged, water contamination is likely to get worse affecting health of humans and cattle.

Clean air and clean water are critical and so are reductions in polluting emissions. There are policy proposals introduced in the U.S. Congress to transition towards clean energy sources but we need a political will and bipartisan approach to drive this transition for improved quality of life for all.

Kalpana Sutaria

Project Manager, City of Austin and Member, Citizens’ Climate Lobby Austin

April 20, 2023

LTE: Methane Has More Than 80 Times the Warming Power of Carbon Dioxide

Re: February 5, 2023 article, “How can we best measure Methane?”

Methane has more than 80 times the warming power of carbon dioxide for twenty years after its release. Under the Inflation Reduction Act, the EPA is preparing to charge a fee, the first ever to reduce global warming, on the amount of methane released.  How to measure the amount is a major dilemma.

Oil and gas companies have equipment to measure methane but they are not deploying them fully. Currently, they can pollute our environment without any consequences. They even burn excess hydrocarbons or use “flaring” which is allowed only for safety.  This practice is widely prevalent in the Permian Basin which TCEQ could stop by enforcement of the current permitting rules.

If these companies don’t want to pay fees, they could follow the permitting rules and seal methane leaks and start a transition plan to clean energy methods to become a part of the solution to stabilize our climate.

Kalpana Sutaria

Project Manager, City of Austin and Member, Citizens Climate Lobby Austin Chapter

Submitted to the Austin American Statesman and to the Times-Picayune in Louisiana

February 2023

Opinion: Texas leaders determined to stop progress on measures to reduce air pollution

Re: January 13 2023, Texas Tribune article, “EPA Moves away from Permian Basin air pollution crackdown”.

Texas leaders are determined to stop progress on measures to reduce air pollution by oil and gas operations in the Permian Basin no matter what it does to Texans’ health. Oil and gas companies have wielded their power for many years and continue to do that. the Biden administration is trying to lower oil prices after oil shortages around the world after the invasion of Ukraine by Russia. Oil companies have pressurized Texas leaders enough for the EPA to back down from air pollution crackdown.

We need policies that can reduce our dependence on oil and gas and encourage clean energy research and development. Ask your members of Congress to enact laws to transition away from pollution causing energy sources to clean energy that would lower ozone levels and improve air quality. I suffer from pollution regularly.

We want leaders who would work for their constituents’ health and well- being.

Kalpana Sutaria

Project Manager, City of Austin and Member, Citizens’ Climate Lobby Austin Chapter

Submitted to the Austin American-Statesman

January 2023